Showing posts with label construction employment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label construction employment. Show all posts

Saturday, 13 December 2025

Long-run Employment in Australian Construction 1986 - 2025

Industry and occupation data for construction and related industries


There is a widely held view that one of the biggest problems in Australian construction is a lack of workers. The previous post was on Infrastructure Australia’s 2025 report on industry capacity and their estimate of a current shortage of 202,000 infrastructure workers and a peak shortage of 420,000 workers in 2027. The Housing Industry Association claims an 83,000 ‘tradies shortfall’, and the Master Builders Association’s 2024 Future of the Workforce report said the industry needed to replace 110,000 retirements a year with another 130,000 workers required to meet demand. 

How accurate and realistic are these claims? Without doubt there are local shortages of workers, especially in regional areas where supply is limited by the size and age of the local population, because the regions are typically older and this is where many of the transmission lines and energy generation projects are located. Also, when too many major projects are commenced at the same time there will be labour shortages and cost increases, like the three Queensland LNG plants in 2014, transport projects in Sydney and Melbourne over the last few years, and probably for the 2032 Olympic Games in Brisbane. However, overwhelming the supply chain by simultaneously running too many major projects is evidence of poor understanding and management of the major project pipeline, not of worker shortages.

Industry capacity for construction is not like manufacturing or other industries with fixed plant and equipment and factories. In a factory or power plant the quantity and availability of that fixed capital puts an identifiable physical limit on output. In construction there will be an upper limit on capacity, but that is not fixed in the same way because output can always be increased by adding more workers, which is what happened in the apartment boom between 2015 and 2018. 

The other way construction adjusts to increasing demand is increasing project delivery times. Capacity is limited by availability, and resources get spread over more work as new projects are started. Materials supply is fixed in the short-run, and the available labour supply will  get exhausted. The result is fewer people on a site and slower progress of ongoing work. At high levels of demand, lead times and cycle times increase and there are more bottlenecks in the supply chain.

In 2025 there are 1.35 million people employed in Construction, and another 330,000 in Architecture, engineering and surveying. In fact, there are more people employed in construction now than at any time in the past, with Construction employment at record highs. This is also the case for many of the trades and professional services. How can the reports and forecasts of shortages be reconciled with the data? 

This post looks at the long-run data on employment in construction and related industries and occupations, which is available from 1986 to 2025 from Jobs and Skills Australia. The data shows trends over time, not current conditions. However, changes in employment patterns happen slowly, and trends clearly show those changes, and are powerful indicators of the number of people that may be employed in the near future.


Jobs and Skills Australia Data

In the following figures the number of people employed is based on Jobs and Skills Australia (JSA) Industry Trends and Occupation Trends, that use data from the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) Labour Force Survey smoothed by JSA to identify long-term trends. While the ABS does seasonal adjustment and trending at aggregate levels, the ABS detailed industry and occupation data are released as original data series only. JSA provides disaggregated data for those detailed labour force estimates, in ‘a heavily smoothed long-term trend’ that will not reflect short-term changes in current conditions. The JSA Trending Methodology is explained here.


Industry Data

The ABS industry classification system has four levels: Division, Subdivision, Group and Class. Construction is Division E, and Table 1 has the breakdown of the industry into its three Subdivisions, eight Groups and twenty-four Classes. JSA’s Industry Trends uses this classification system and employment data is available from 1986.


Table 1. Division E Construction

Source: ABS Australian and New Zealand Standard Industrial Classification 


Occupation Data

JSA employment by occupation data is available as Occupation Trends from 1986. An ‘occupation’ is defined as a group of similar tasks or jobs based on five skill levels and skill specialisations like knowledge, tools and materials. The classification system  has five levels: eight major groups, 53 sub-major groups, 111 minor groups, 421 unit groups, and 1,156 occupations [1]. There are also workers in a ‘not further defined’ (nfd)  category, who cannot be classified to an occupation but are included in a group. There is a loose alignment with the industry classification system at the sub-group level, but it is not exact. Using Bricklayers as an example of the classification structure:

Major Group – Technicians and Trades Workers

Sub-major Group – Building Structural Trades Workers

Minor Group – Bricklayers, Stonemasons and Concreters

Unit Group – Bricklayers and Stonemasons

Occupation - Bricklayers


Construction Employment 

Figure 1 shows the effect of JSA’s smoothing of the quarterly rises and falls in Construction employment into a long-term trend line. The figure shows the increase in the total number employed in since 1986, with the value of work done adjusted for inflation (the ABS chain volume measure of output) for comparison. The relationship is clear, except for the mining boom that started in 2007 and ran to 2104. Because expenditure on imported plant and equipment like oil platforms, mining machinery and gas liquefaction systems was included in the value of construction work done during the mining boom, this artificially boosted its value before falling once the boom was over. 

Figure 1. Employment and work done

Note: Work done is chain volume measure, seasonally adjusted trend. 

Sources: ABS 8755 and JSA Industry Trends.


Apart from the mining boom there are three points of interest. The first is the sustained rise in both work done and employment from the mid-1990s to the mid-2000s, as employment closely tracked the increasing value of work done. The second is the sharp increase in employment in 2015 at the start of the residential building and apartment boom that followed the mining boom. The third is the three years after 2021 as employment increased faster than work done, which increased with excessive Homebuilder subsidies and grants [2]. 

In August 2021 there were 1.148 million people employed in Construction, in August 2022 that had risen to 1.242 million, in August 2023 to 1.321 million, and in August 2024 1.342 million were employed. This was an increase of almost 200,000 in three years, of which 120,000 were in Construction services as a result of the apprentice incentive schemes introduced during the Pandemic. 


Construction Contractors 

Figure 2 has employment by the three contractor groups. The 512,700 total includes trades directly employed by these firms as well as other professionals, managers and office workers. There are also workers in a ‘not further defined’ (nfd)  category, who cannot be classified to an occupation but are included in the Building subdivision. The rapid increase in their numbers over the last few years suggests many of these workers are in new occupations not yet in the classification system, examples could be BIM managers, heat pump and solar panel installers. The increase in Building nfd started with the Covid incentive schemes. 


Figure 2. Employment by contractor groups


 Source: JSA Industry Trends


In Engineering there has been a significant structural shift in the ratio of professionals to technicians. In 1986 there were two Civil engineering professionals to each Civil engineering draftsperson and technician, by 2025 there were five professionals for each draftsperson and technician. 


Figure 3. Civil Engineering

Source: JSA Occupation Trends


Figure 4 has the number employed for Construction managers and Trades workers. Between 1986 and 2025 the number of managers increased from 43,300 to 131,400 and Trades workers from 244,400 to 414,000. What is significant is the change in the ratio of managers to workers, which was just over 6 in the late 1990s and early 2000s but then fell to 3.2 in the 2020s. Between 2006 and 2025 the number of managers doubled, from 61,200 to 131,400, while trades workers went from 344,500 to 414,000, so over those two decades the increase in both was almost the same at 70,200 for managers and 69,500 for trades workers. For every extra trades worker there was another manager. This is telling us something important about the industry, and is probably one of the reasons there has been no increase in measured productivity. 


Figure 4. Construction managers and Trades workers


 Source: JSA Occupation Trends


JSA defines Construction Managers as workers who ‘plan, organise, direct, control and coordinate the construction of civil engineering projects, buildings and dwellings, and the physical and human resources involved in building and construction.’ Their tasks are: interpret drawings  and specifications, coordinate labour and implement work programs, coordinate procurement and delivery of materials, plant and equipment, prepare tenders and bids, ensure adherence to building legislation and standards, arrange inspections, and negotiate with stakeholders. Construction Managers are broken down into two specific roles. In 2025 there were 60,200 Construction project managers and 47,800 Project builders. Construction Project Managers manage civil engineering and building projects, while Project Builders manage the construction, alteration and renovation of dwellings and other buildings. 


Construction Trades

Figure 5 has the five Construction services industry groups. Building installation services have had the largest increase in numbers, from 105,000 in 1986 to 320,000 workers in 2025, and is now by far the largest group. The other group with a significant increase is Building completion services, which increased from 76,000 to 210,000 and is the second largest group. These groups both rose by around three times. They include electrical, HVAC, plumbing, carpentry and painting, and the increase in their numbers reflects increasing complexity and the rising share of building services in the total cost.

Other building services had the biggest increase of over four times, going from 31,000 in 1986 to 134,000 in 2025, with most of that increase due to Machinery operators. Building structure employment increased from to 106,000, and Land development and site preparation had the smallest increase of only 26,000 workers, going from 31,000 to 57,000. 


Figure 5. Employment in Construction services groups

Source: JSA Industry Trends


Figures 6, 7 and 8 have employment by occupation for construction trades, grouped by size. Electricians are by far the largest. Figure 6 has the three largest occupations and shows a significant increase in the number of electricians and plumbers, both of whose numbers have more than doubled since the mid-1990s. In Figure 7, over the last couple of decades the number of Bricklayers has fallen and the number of Plasterers barely changed, however there are more Painting trades people. 


Figure 6. Carpenters, electricians and plumbers


 Source: JSA Occupation Trends


Figure 7. Bricklayers, painters and plasterers

Source: JSA Occupation Trends


Figure 8 has the four smallest trades of Floor finishers, Glaziers and Tilers. The number of Wall and floor tilers has more than doubled to over 22,000, but Floor finishers, Glaziers and Roof tilers each have around 10,000 workers, have had no increase over the last two decades, and are the trades occupations with the lowest numbers. 


Figure 8. Floor finishers, glaziers and tilers

Source: JSA Occupation Trends



There have been small increases in the number of Crane, hoist and lift operators and Earthmoving plant operators. The former went from 12,200 in 1986 to 16,900 in 2025, while Earthmoving plant operator numbers increased from 38,600 to 49,100. This interesting because there has been little increase in the number of machinery operators but a large increase in the volume of work done. The Q3 2025 the RLB Crane Index had 845 cranes in use in Australia, above the long-term average of 775. 


Figure 9. Crane and earthmoving operators

Source: JSA Occupation Trends
 

Finally, Figure 10 has Construction labourers. There was a total of 192,100 in 2025, almost all in construction. The two largest occupations are Building and plumbing labourers with 71,500 and Concreters with 37,200 employed in 2025. For the other occupations, Structural steel and Insulation had around 25,000, and Fencers 13,000. 


Figure 10. Construction labourers 

Source: JSA Occupation Trends


Professional and Technical Services

Figure 11 has Construction work done and employment in the Architectural, engineering and technical services industry group that is part of the Scientific, technical and professional services industry. Employment increased from in 1986 to in 2025. The JSA smoothed trend shows a remarkably consistent increase. The overall pattern is similar to Construction work, with a turning point in the mid-1980s when the growth rate sharply increased, a flattening out of growth in the mid-2010s, and higher recent growth. 


Figure 11. Professional services and work don 

Note: Work done is chain volume measure.

Sources: ABS 8755 and JSA Industry Trends


Figure 12 has the number of architects and surveyors. They total 51,000 in 2025, of which 29,600 were Architects and landscape architects, however on the JSA website in 2025 there were 3,800 Landscape architects and 19,300 Architects. Thus there are around 6,000 other employed people in this category who are neither, which may be where people working on digital twins and BIM end up because Architects prepare ‘project documentation, including sketches and scale drawings, and integrate structural, mechanical and aesthetic elements in final designs.’


Figure 12. Architects and surveyors

Source: JSA Occupational Trends


Figure 13 has two other occupations. In 2025 there were 173,700 Contract, program and project administrators, and their numbers have steadily increased from only 14,000 in 1988, and in 1986 there were 30,500 Architectural, building and surveying technicians with 83,800 employed in 2025.  These employees would be spread across a number of industry groups based on the classification of their employer as a construction contractor or subcontractors, architecture or surveying practice, or project manager (classified as a business service).


Figure 13. Technicians and administrators

Source: JSA Occupation Trends


Construction Manufacturing Industries

Along with trade and contractor employment there are many people employed in manufacturing industries that supply construction. Onsite construction brings together a wide range of materials and components, for example a detached house would typically have around five thousand different items and a ten story office building could have up to fifty thousand items. The following figures have the industry employment data for seven manufacturing industries that produce construction inputs.


Figure 14. Timber and wood products

 

Source: JSA Industry Trends


The general pattern in manufacturing has been a long-term decline in employment, but there is wide variation. In Figure 14, Sawmilling and timber dressing employment has fallen from 17,000 in 1986 to almost halve by 2025 at 9,000, while Other wood products has  only declined by 4,000 workers, from 31,000 to 27,000 in 2025. In Figure 15, Structural steel has not changed but Other fabricated metal fell from 51,000 in 1996  to 21,000 in 2014, while Heating, compressors and ventilation equipment employment has no changed. 


Figure 15. Metal and HVAC  

Source: JSA Industry Trends


In Figure 16, employment in glass products has been quite stable, also in Ceramic products after 2006. The big decline has been in Cement and concrete, falling from 26,000 in 1986 to 11,000 in 2025. That is not because less cement and concrete is being produced. Although the ABS no longer publishes production volumes, the industry output and value added for the Cement, lime, plaster and concrete manufacturing industry class has continued to increase as employment fell.


Figure 16. Concrete, glass and ceramics

Source: JSA Industry Trends


Conclusion

The Jobs and Skills Australia (JSA) employment data this post uses goes back to 1986. It is available as Industry Trends, at the five ANZSIC levels, and as Occupation Trends, for over 1,000 different occupations. The JSA trending methodology is particularly good at clarifying long-term trends as it smooths the ups and downs in the quarterly data from the ABS Labour Force survey, and by disaggregating and trending the ABS data for industry classes and occupations it provides detailed data on the workforce not available elsewhere.

What does the data say? First, the long-run trend for total Construction employment shows it increasing, and the trend in employment has tracked changes in the volume of work don, with the exception being the unusual circumstances of the mining boom. This is particularly noticeable with the sharp increases in employment in the late 2010s during the apartment boom and then after 2021 with the introduction of HomeBuilder subsidies and apprentice incentive schemes. This suggests that in the right circumstances employment numbers in Construction can be increased quickly. In particular, the combination of a rapid rise in work and the highly effective apprentice incentive schemes introduced in 2021 led to a rapid increase in the number of trades people employed. 

Second, there have been a few occupations with very large increases, notably Contract, program and project administrators at 173,000 have twelve times as many people employed in 2025 compared to 1986. Many of those workers will be employed by contractors, and have contributed to the rise in employment seen in the Residential building and Engineering industry groups. In Construction services Installation and Building completion services had much larger increases than the other industry groups, and the occupations Electricians, Plumbers and Wall and floor tilers have doubled employment since 2006. 

Third, many of the trade occupations have had little or no growth in numbers since 2006. Bricklayers, concreters, roof tilers, floor finishers, plasterers and glaziers are all in this category. There has been no growth in the Land development and site preparation industry group, reflected in the stable number of earthmoving operators over the last few decades. However, the number of Crane, hoist and lift operators has increased by half since 2006 to 17,000.

Fourth is the role of technicians. In 2025 there were 51,000 Architects and Surveyors, but 83,000 Architecture, building and surveying technicians, increasing from 31,000 in 1986. Engineering went the other way. From two Civil engineering professionals to each Civil engineering draftsperson and technician in 1986, by 2025 there were five professionals for each draftsperson and technician. 

Fifth is the change in the ratio of Construction managers to trades workers, which was just over 6 in the late 1990s and early 2000s but fell to 3.2 in the 2020s. Between 2006 and 2025 for every extra trades worker there was another manager, as the number of managers went from 61,200 to 131,400 and trades workers went from 344,500 to 414,000, with the increase in both almost the same at 70,200 for managers and 69,500 for trades workers. Along with the increased number of Contract, program and project administrators, this must be part of the explanation of the low rate of productivity growth in the industry. 

If changes in employment trends vary greatly across the industry groups and occupations what do the forecasts of worker shortages mean? Do shortages mean projects are not started because workers are not available, or lead times increase, or projects take longer to deliver because the workforce is spread over many projects? Are there more delays and bottlenecks due to such shortages? The example of residential building during the HomeBuilder Program is clear. The program quickly increased housing commencements to record levels but completion times also increased, and it took three years to complete the extra 100,000 houses commenced in 2020 and 2021. Completion times for houses doubled during the pandemic.


Figure 17. Residential building


 

Obviously, there will be shortages at certain times in certain places, but those specific instances should not be generalised to the industry. Equally, sudden shifts in demand, like large infrastructure projects or the current energy transition, can also see short-term shortages. Without suggesting there are no and will never be any shortages, claims about current and future shortages have to be seen as just that, they are claims not facts. 

Another problem is the short-term nature of forecasts of shortages. They are typically only a few years into the future, and the long-term data clearly shows employment in the industry adjusts to both the level of demand and the demand for specific skills. The industry groups of Residential building and Engineering have seen solid increases in employment over the last couple of decades, and that is where the demand has been, and the increase in the number of electricians and project administrators reflects changes in the demand for skills. 

Construction is a project-based industry, and capacity is largely determined by the availability of labour, skills and expertise. Output is affected by factors like weather, regulations, materials supply, and project timelines. The industry requires specialised skills and uses subcontracting, so the industry is fragmented and has many small firms, but adding firms also increases capacity. All those characteristics make it difficult to define the maximum output for the industry, so claims and forecasts of worker and skill shortages are at best estimates that reflect assumptions about the ability of the industry to adapt and grow. The long-run data shows Construction employment tracks the level of work done, the exception being the mining boom, and has seen the number of people employed increase when demand and the volume of work increase. Capacity is a concept that has to be used carefully for the construction industry, balancing an estimate of maximum output with the effect on project performance of high levels of activity.


Saturday, 8 February 2025

The Changing Composition of Construction Employment

 Data from Australia and the United States

 


 

One of the curious things about the construction industry is the perception of it as inefficient and technologically backward, yet it has been at the forefront of many scientific and technical advance for centuries. From Gothic cathedrals to railways and airport terminals, building and construction projects have bought together the best available resources to create increasingly complex structures using the best available technology. Demand for new types of structures with greatly improved capabilities in strength and span drove the development of the modern industry during the first industrial revolution in the nineteenth century. To buildiron-framed and steel-reinforced concrete buildings the industry had to not only master the use of these new materials but also develop the processes and project management skills the new technology required, with the roles of engineers, architects, quantity surveyors, contractors, subcontractors and suppliers becoming defined by the beginning of the twentieth century. The issue then, like today, was not the availability of jobs but the quality of skills during the adoption of new technologies by the industry. 

 

The industry has an undeserved reputation as a technological laggard and for low skilled workers. In reality, the nature of the work attracts people with technical skills who use ‘technological thinking’ to find solutions to the problems a project will encounter between inception and delivery. Technological thinking is essentially problem-solving through trial and error. Regardless of which part of construction they work in, for the vast majority of these people there is a great deal of satisfaction in doing this work well, following relevant codes of practice and meeting the required standards.

 

This post looks at data on construction employment, qualifications and occupations in the Australian and United States industries. It is not a comparison, because the data is not the same, but an attempt to relate changes in the composition of the workforce to changes in the industry, such as the volume and nature of work and the types of projects. Given the data, this analysis can only be indicative and the conclusions tentative. However, there is good evidence that the industry is neither a technological laggard nor an industry with an unqualified and low skilled workforce, and that these are common misperceptions and misrepresentations of construction. 

 

 

Australian Construction Employment Trends

 

Employment in the Australian industry has grown strongly over the last couple of decades, from 664,993 people in November 2000 to 994,283 in November 2010 to 1,363,057 in November 2024 [1], and over that period there has been both stability and change in the composition of the workforce. The percentage share of Technicians and trades has been and is around 50% of the workforce, similarly Labourers have accounted for 16-17% since 2000. During the mining boom the share of Machinery operators and drivers rose to 9% in 2012, but had fallen to 6% by 2024, the lowest share since 2000. As Figure 1 shows, the combined share of these onsite workers rose from 75% in 2000 to 77% in 2012, and was 73% in 2024. 

 

Figure 1. Australian construction workforce composition


 

Source: ABS 6291 Employed persons by Industry division and Occupation.

 

 

It is in the other occupations that the major changes have been happening, and here the trends have been long-running and gradual. The share of Clerical and administrative workers has steadily declined from 12.5% in 2000 to 8.5% in 2024, falling by a third over that time. The share of professionals was 2% in 2000, 4% in 2012 and 6% in 2024. And the share of Managers has increased from 9% in 2000 to 12% in 2016, where it has been since. As Figure 2 shows, the increase in the share of professionals has been the most significant change in workforce composition.

 

Figure 2. Australian construction workforce composition

 


Source: ABS 6291 Employed persons by Industry division and Occupation.

 

Putting the numbers of people employed in different occupations adds some perspective. This data does not go back past 2023 because of the introduction of a revised classification system for occupations, however over the relatively short period between August 2023 and November 2024 there were some significant changes. In particular, the number of Professionals increased from 61,900 to 81,100, a dramatic change, and the number of Community and personal service workers went from 1,100 to 3,200. The number of Managers and labourers also increased, but Clerical and Sales worker numbers both fell, as did the number of Machinery operators. 

 

Table 1. Australian construction, number employed ‘000, by occupation


Source: ABS 6291 Employed persons by Industry division and Occupation.

 

Finally, another Australian Bureau of Statistics publication has qualifications and work by industry, and table 2 shows that two thirds of construction workers have gained a qualification after leaving school, and 14% have a bachelor degree or higher. 

 

Table 2. Construction workers by level of qualification


Source: ABS Education and Work, May 2024. 

 

The Australian Computer Society’s 2024 Digital Pulse report found Construction employed 12,512 technology workers (in information technology and telecommunications jobs), with 4,983 in management and operations, 2,970 in technical and professional, and 4,559 in ICT trades. That does not include the technology workers employed by the architecture, engineering and project management firms in the Professional, Scientific and technical services industry (possibly 10% of a total of 138,058 outside Computer system design and services).

 

United States Construction Employment Trends

 

In the U.S. the data is organised differently, and there are no qualifications by industry data available. There have been significant changes in the composition of the construction workforce, particularly in the last few years. For most years from 2000 to 2009 the Nonproduction employees share of total employment was between 22 and 23%, then from 2009 to mid-2017 it was 24% before rising to 25% at the end of 2017. In 2020 the share rose again to 26% and by 2024 was up to 27.5%. The number of Nonproduction employees in December 2000 was 1,503,000 and almost the same in 2014 at 1,553,000. From 2015 the number began increasing, to 1,903,000 in 2020 and 2,069,000 in 2022, and reached 2,284,000 in 2024 [2].  

 

Figure 3. US construction employment

 


Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Production and Nonsupervisory Employees, Construction, All Employees, Construction, retrieved from ALFRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

 

 

Another series from the U.S. has a similar pattern, for the number of Managers employed in Construction in January. Employment of Managers was 335,000 in 2000 and 414,000 in 2013, before it started increasing and almost doubled, going from 428,000 in 2014 to 785,000 in 2024. Because this was a much larger increase than the increase in Nonproduction employees over that period, the share of Managers in Nonproduction employees went from 22% in 2020 to 26% in 2013 to 32% in 2022, and was 34% in2024 [3].

 

Figure 4. Number of managers employed in U.S. construction

 


Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Employed full time: Wage and salary workers: Construction managers occupations: 16 years and over, retrieved from FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

 

These trends in U.S. construction employment suggest a change in the industry around 2014-15. Total construction spending was recovering from the downturn after the recession in 2008-09, when monthly spending fell below $800 million, and was back to $1 billion in 2014. By 2020 the monthly spend was up to $1.5 billion. By historical standards this was a solid recovery but not exceptional. However, between 2020 and 2024 the total spend went up to $2.15 billion, driven by a doubling of manufacturing construction to $236 million a month as a result of the Biden Administration’s industrial policies that provided subsidies to build semiconductor fabs, data centres, grid infrastructure and renewable energy sites

 

With that increase in manufacturing construction, the number of Nonproduction employees and construction Managers also increased. The timing of this cannot be a coincidence, and could be attributed to the complexity and scale of the chip fabs, data centres and other computer and energy projects underway due the subsidies provided by the Biden Administration. Further, the change in employment was a break in the existing trend of gradually increasing employment of Nonproduction employees and construction Managers. The inflection point was 2021. 

 

Figure 5. U.S. total construction spending, seasonally adjusted

 


Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Total Construction Spending: Total Construction in the United States, retrieved from FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. 

 

The U.S. Bureau Of labour Statistics has detailed occupational data for 2023, but unfortunately this is not available for earlier surveys so a comparison cannot be made. However, the 2023 data is useful because it has the number employed in construction in managerial, supervisory or technical support occupations across the industry divisions of trades, non-residential and residential building, and engineering. These total 1,030,370 people, or 13% of total construction employment in 2023 of 8,120,000, which would the other half of Nonproduction employees that are not cost estimators or doing other clerical and administrative work. Many of these employees can be assumed to have a bachelor degree, for example it is a requirement for construction and architectural managers. 

 

As Table 3 shows, the great majority are employed as trades supervisors (609,580) and construction managers (266,140). The third largest category is architecture and engineering (103,940). The fourth is computer occupations (22,080), and fifth OH&S (19,600). The others are compliance officers (5,660) and architectural managers (3,370). 

 

Table 3. Number employed by occupation and industry division in May 2023



Note 1: The number here of Managers and Supervisors combined is more than the number of Construction Managers in Figure 2 above. 

Note 2: Compliance Officers evaluate conformity with laws and regulations governing licenses and permits, and excludes Occupational Health and Safety and Construction and Building Inspectors. 

Source: U.S. Bureau Of labour Statistics, Occupational Employment and Wages

 

 

Trades requiring qualifications like equipment operators (321,730), electricians (558,750), plumbers (384,870) and building inspectors (13,550) employed another 1,278,900 people. Adding these trade workers to the 1,030,370 managers and professionals above gives 2,309,270 and 28% of total construction employment in 2023 of 8,120,000. There were another 2,475,690 people employed in construction trades in 2023 as bricklayers, plasterers, painters etc., and many but not all of these workers would also have a certificate or diploma qualification. When the three groups are combined, this is over half the total number of employees. The BLS number of unqualified and unskilled workers was small, there were 858,900 laborers and 174,200 construction trades helpers.

 

Change Drivers

 

What can account for these changes in the composition construction employment in Australia and the U.S.? There are three reasons that are widely agreed on. The first is increased regulation, compliance and planning leading to more people spending more time to meet those requirements. In the U.S. there is the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), federal environmental legislation requires agencies to produce an environmental impact statement (EIS) before the project can start. These statements can be thousands of pages long and take years to prepare, and NEPA is a frequent target of criticism and reform efforts [4]. Some stats from a Thomas Hochman post on NEPA in December:

  • Average environmental impact statement preparation time is 4.2 years as of 2022 
  • Average review time grew from 3.4 years in 2008 to 4+ years by 2015, increasing by an average of 37 days per year
  • Average delay from environmental review publication to resolution of legal challenge: 4.2 years
  • Even a "finding of no significant impact" can take extensive time and documentation (1,200+ pages in one case)
  • Up to $400 million spent just on regulatory/environmental review process for major projects
  • Solar projects: 64% litigation rate
  • 72% of NEPA litigation initiated by NGOs

 

In Australia planning rules are highly prescriptive and complex, with zoning, other regulations, and lengthy development approval processes reducing the ability of housing markets to respond to demand. Research on apartment prices in 2020 and house prices in 2018 by the Reserve bank found planning and zoning restrictions raised prices by up to 70%. A 2021 survey by Infrastructure Australia found: ‘Contractors and investors viewed planning and environmental approval processes as an unpredictable risk to project timelines and a driver of delay. The need to coordinate across multiple layers of government to obtain approvals, and the requirement to meet increasingly onerous conditions attached to many approvals, (e.g. in relation environmental approvals) prompted concern over delivery times’ (p.44). 

 

A second reason is the digitisation of construction and use of BIM leading to increasing offsite employment and project planning. A 2023 Brookings Institute report found only 23% of U.S. jobs were ‘low digitalisation’ in 2020 compared to 52% in 2003. From 2002 to 2010 the share of occupations with a high digitalization level doubled, from 9% to 18%, and in 2020 rose to 26%. A 2021 report by RMIT University found that 87% of jobs in Australia require digital literacy skills, and the 2024 submission by Industry Skills Australia to the Commonwealth Government’s Inquiry into the Digital Transformation of Workplaces (available here with all the other submissions) predicted only 45% of construction jobs would not be impacted by digital technology by 2030.

 

And a similar argument has increasing offsite manufacturing reducing the number of workers onsite and raising the proportion of offsite workers. The actual extent of the effect is unknown, but is likely to be marginal as the point is not replacing workers but moving them offsite, and there is still substantial site preparation and assembly work involved. Offsite manufacturing also requires detailed digital design and production planning work. 

 

Conclusion

 

The construction industry is neither a technological laggard nor an industry with an unqualified and low skilled workforce. These are common misperceptions that probably are often the result of people seeing poorly organised and managed sites, which could be addressed through better site facilities and maintenance. In fact, the industry employs a wide range of skills and requires technical competence from the majority of its workers. In Australia, two thirds of the workforce have a post-school qualification, and in the U.S. it is over half. In both countries the share of unskilled labourers is small, at around 10% of the workforce [5]. 

 

There are other interesting parallels between Australia and the U.S. In Australia, the share of professionals rose from 2% in 2000 to 6% in 2024, and the share of Managers increased from 9% in 2000 to 12%. Adding the 2024 8% share of Clerical and administrative workers makes 26% in these occupations. In the U.S. between 2014 and 2020 the share of Nonproduction employees rose from 24% to 26%. In both countries the number of Managers has increased by 50%. The share of workers with a bachelors degree or higher is also the same, around 14%.

 

Why, despite the differences in scale and output mix in the two countries, is the composition of the workforce so similar? To some extent it must be because the methods and processes followed in design, development, construction and project management are similar, as is the use of machinery and equipment. There is not a lot of difference in some types of projects, such as commercial and institutional buildings and road and rail infrastructure. Another factor would be the geographical dispersion of activity, both are large countries and work is spread out across regions. 

 

The trend in both countries is toward fewer low skilled jobs, and this applies to both onsite labourers and offsite clerical and administrative workers. An increasing share of jobs requires qualifications, and more of these workers have university qualifications. This is not to suggest there will be no unskilled workers in future construction, but there is no reason to believe these trends have run their course. 

 

                                                                            *

 

[1] Discussed in a previous post Australian Construction and the Shortage of Workers

[2] Production employees include working supervisors and all nonsupervisory employees engaged in production operations. Nonsupervisory employees includes office and clerical workers, repairers, salespersons, operators, drivers, laborers and other employees at similar occupational levels. 
[3] Construction Managers: Plan, direct, or coordinate, usually through subordinate supervisory personnel, activities concerned with the construction and maintenance of structures, facilities, and systems. Participate in the conceptual development of a construction project and oversee its organization, scheduling, budgeting, and implementation. Includes managers in specialized construction fields, such as carpentry or plumbing. From the Bureau Of labour Statistics 
Standard Occupational Classification

[4] For a history and how NEPA works see Brian Potter https://www.construction-physics.com/p/how-nepa-works. For a survey of research see Noah Smith https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/the-big-nepa-roundup. For comprehensive data see Thomas Hochman https://www.greentape.pub/p/nepastats and why reform is necessary https://www.greentape.pub/p/revisiting-pro-nepa-studies  

[5]  The review of the UK's ITBs by Mark Farmer has just been released. It was done in 2023 and the data is for 2020, but it says on page 41:

"In terms of the job role make up of the construction industry, 57% are elementary level, plant or trade craft operatives. Professional, management and technical roles constitute 33% of the workforce with 10% of the workforce are in support or administrative roles.

In terms of attainment, 73% of the workforce are at level 3 and below, including 5% who are unqualified. 21% are degree level or above qualified."

Interesting because similar to Australia and the US.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/2023-industry-training-board-itb-review


Subscribe on Substack here

https://gerarddevalence.substack.com/